Chapter 455 Why should I take responsibility?
Gao Jiantong came to Gu Chen’s law firm and presented him with a banner.
He gave Gu Chen another banner.
Gu Chen and Xue Qingqing had just returned to the law firm. No rest yet.
Yan Yuting came over and said: "Boss, there is another case today. It is extremely urgent. Someone wants to bring a lawsuit against you."
Ordinary cases would not be litigated by Gu Chen.
The case submitted by the assistant shows that this case is relatively complicated.
Yan Yuting said: "And the client said that he must find lawyer Gu to fight this lawsuit. It is impossible to find anyone else."
Gu Chen said: "What case?"
< br>Yan Yuting gave the information to Gu Chen.
Gu Chen took the information and took a look at it.
The content of the case is this.
A woman named Huang Rong, who came from a pretty good family, received a call from her home on the morning of July 6.
An old man in the family passed away and Huang Rong was asked to go home as soon as possible.
So Huang Rong packed her suitcase and decided to take the high-speed rail home.
Huang Rong was queuing up to check in. She put her suitcase behind her without leaving it in a mess.
Everyone is queuing up to check in as usual.
As a result, at this time, a middle-aged man named Wang Zonglei took his mother Fan Lijun with him.
They queued at this ticket gate for a long time and found that they had gone to the wrong ticket gate.
So, while holding the ticket, Wang Zonglei looked for the correct ticket gate.
Wang Zonglei stopped queuing and went to find a new ticket gate.
Wang Zonglei’s mother Fan Lijun is over sixty years old.
Fan Lijun also followed Wang Zonglei and stopped queuing, preparing to leave.
Just as Fan Lijun was leaving, she passed by Huang Rong.
Then Fan Lijun didn't notice the suitcase behind Huang Rong and tripped over the suitcase.
Fan Lijun lost her center of gravity. After falling, Wang Zonglei immediately came back to care about Fan Lijun.
Huang Rong also noticed that Fan Lijun had fallen and quickly went forward to check the situation.
At that time, Fan Lijun felt that nothing was wrong with her. She just felt a little dizzy and it was not a big problem.
Fan Lijun didn’t even know that she had hit the back of her head.
Fan Lijun waved her hand and said it was okay. Both parties were anxious to get on the bus, so they exchanged contact information and left.
As a result, Fan Lijun said after arriving at the station that she had a headache and was getting more and more dizzy.
After being sent to the hospital, it was discovered that he had a cerebral hemorrhage.
Things got big after that.
The old lady Fan Lijun was sent to the hospital for treatment. At the same time, Wang Zonglei also contacted Huang Rong and explained the situation.
Wang Zonglei asked Huang Rong to come to the hospital to advance money, saying that the old lady Fan Lijun was in the hospital now because of Huang Rong.
If she hadn't hit Huang Rong's suitcase, the old lady would not have gone to the hospital.
So Wang Zonglei felt that Huang Rong must bear the responsibility.
Wang Zonglei kept asking Huang Rong for money, but Huang Rong also felt aggrieved.
The old lady didn’t have eyes or see the road. She bumped into her suitcase. What does it have to do with her?
Besides, there is no problem with the location of Huang Rong's suitcase. Huang Rong did not place the suitcase randomly, but just placed it behind her.
Someone bumped into her suitcase, but she was held responsible?
Wang Zonglei directly asked Huang Rong for the treatment cost of 300,000 yuan. Huang Rong said that she was not responsible and she had no money to pay for the medical expenses.
Huang Rong said that she would not go to the hospital and she would not take responsibility.
And Wang Zonglei has always asked Huang Rong to take responsibility and make Huang Rong pay
Both parties have been making trouble about this matter.
In the end, Fan Lijun was treated in the hospital for fifteen days.
As for whether it can be cured, it is hard to say, because Fan Lijun is already over sixty years old and an old man.
Wang Zonglei saw that Huang Rong was unwilling to take responsibility, so he communicated with her again .
Wang Zonglei finally decided to give up treatment.
In the end, Fan Lijun died of respiratory failure.
After Fan Lijun died, things became even bigger.
Wang Zonglei said that Huang Rong should bear all the responsibilities and even put Huang Rong in jail.
After Huang Rong learned about Fan Lijun's death, she had no choice but to say that she would not bear any responsibility.
Then Wang Zonglei chose to call the police.
At the same time, Wang Zonglei also chose to sue Huang Rong.
Now we have reached the stage of pre-trial mediation. As long as the mediation can be successful, there is no need to enter the prosecution stage.
During the mediation, the mediator was standing aside, and Huang Rong and Wang Zonglei sat face to face.
Wang Zonglei said: "Mediating this matter? My mother left because she bumped into Huang Rong's suitcase, so Huang Rong must bear responsibility. It's good that I don't let Huang Rong bear criminal responsibility. Your luggage killed someone, shouldn't you take responsibility?"
Huang Rong said: "Why should I take responsibility? Why is the suitcase misplaced? Isn’t it just behind me? What responsibility do I have to bear? And what does your mother’s death have to do with me? That’s not what you want to give up. Treatment? "
Wang Zonglei said: "There's no need to talk about it. Just tell me whether my mother was knocked down by your suitcase."
Huang Rong said: "Yeah, so what? What's wrong? Who doesn't bring a suitcase when taking the high-speed train? Isn't it normal to bring a suitcase? I took the car with a suitcase, but your mother bumped into her. I can What should I do? As her son, you went to the ticket gate on your own and ignored you. Mom, your mother bumped into my suitcase, and you blamed me. I didn’t move at that time, and my suitcase didn’t move either. I just stood there, with the suitcase right behind me.”< br>
The incident occurred at a high-speed rail station, so there must have been surveillance video at the time. It was also clear from the surveillance video that Huang Rong did not move.
First, Wang Zonglei looked around for the ticket gate, and only an old lady was left.
As a result, the old lady didn’t look at the road and hit the suitcase directly, and was knocked down
In the end, both the old lady and Wang Zonglei wanted Huang Rong to bear the responsibility.
Wang Zonglei said: "But my mother died. This happened after hitting your suitcase. Just say, if I If my mother hadn't hit your suitcase that day, would this have happened? Would she have left me? Would she have died? "
Huang Rong said, "I'll say it again, your mother died because you gave up. Treatment is not caused by me, you You gave up treatment, so your mother left. If you didn't give up treatment and extubate, how could your mother die of respiratory failure? "
Wang Zonglei said: "This matter is irrelevant. I have to say, you definitely want to You are responsible for my mother’s death. You are not 100% responsible, but you are 99% responsible.”
“I gave up treatment because, as a family member, I have the right to give up treatment.”
"Why did I give up treatment? Because my mother was hit very badly by your suitcase! Hit the back of the head, do you know what that means? Do you know? What's the result? You don't bear a penny, you pay a penny. Why don't you take the money first? My mother was hit, shouldn't you?"
"Isn't it your suitcase that hit my mother? Why don't you take responsibility? If you paid all the treatment fees earlier, how could I give up the treatment? In the end, you didn't even come to the hospital!" > "You hit someone, don't you want to take responsibility? I asked you to advance money, but you didn't advance money. Now that the person is dead, do you say it has nothing to do with you? That's nonsense." Wang Zonglei said.
Huang Rong was speechless.
Huang Rong said; "Let me say it again, I did not hit anyone. Your mother did not see the suitcase due to her own reasons, and then bumped directly into my suitcase. I did not move at that time."
"Moreover, the main reason for your mother's death was that you did not follow the treatment plan given by the doctor, and you did not respond to me and directly chose to give up the treatment, which resulted in your mother's death from respiratory failure."
"If you follow the doctor's orders and treat according to the doctor's treatment plan, your mother will definitely not die. But if you give up the treatment, then your mother's death will have nothing to do with me."
Huang Rong doesn't want to take any responsibility.
What does this have to do with her?
She was standing there, if she really bumped into someone else and knocked them down
If she were to bear criminal responsibility, she would be willing to do so.
But now this matter obviously has nothing to do with her.
Wang Zonglei kept asking her to take responsibility and ask her to bear the medical expenses. It was impossible for her to bear the medical expenses.
Because Huang Rong always felt that this matter had nothing to do with her.
It was obviously Fan Lijun who bumped into her suitcase.
She looked innocent and confused at that time.
Who would have thought that a normal person would bump directly into someone else's suitcase?
Then he tripped and fell, and blamed her for everything.
She was still queuing up to check in, and didn’t even move. Her suitcase was placed behind her, ready to enter the station to check in at any time.
As a result, I encountered such a thing
Huang Rong felt that no matter what, this matter had nothing to do with her.
She does not need to bear any responsibility for this matter.
Wang Zonglei said: "I want to tell you, it was because you didn't manage your suitcase well, which caused my mother to fall. It was all because you didn't manage your own things well, and your suitcase got in the way. Others are walking, which is why others fall. No matter what, you are responsible for this."
"You should think of your actions. The suitcase may hinder the passage of others and cause others to fall, but you did not manage your suitcase well, and your suitcase caused others to fall. Isn't this your responsibility? "
"Let me ask you, if someone is accidentally knocked down by your things, and you say that you have no responsibility, do you think this is appropriate?" Wang Zonglei asked.
Huang Rong said: "I also said, I feel I have no responsibility."
Wang Zonglei said: "Okay, that means the mediation failed, right? Then we can meet in court and file a lawsuit. I will I'm looking for a lawyer to file a lawsuit with you. My mother's death is all because of you. I made it clear to you in advance. I asked. Your behavior first caused my mother to be brought down, and then you refused to come. The hospital visited my mother and refused to pay the medical expenses, causing my mother's death. You will be held criminally responsible for this behavior. Once we go to court, you may be sentenced."
"Because. It was your fault that caused my mother's death. You can't escape this responsibility. We can meet in court. I believe my teacher will explain these things clearly to you," Wang Zonglei said.
"Then we'll see you in court. I don't care. If you can hire a lawyer, I can hire one too," Huang Rong said.
Huang Rong has always felt that she was wronged by this matter.
Her suitcase was always behind her
She didn't say anything about tampering with the suitcase. She placed the suitcase in a place that would affect the normal passage of others.
She was queuing normally at the time, with her suitcase behind her, and did not affect the passage of others, nor did she think about deliberately knocking others down.
As a result, something happened after Fan Lijun was knocked down. , all responsibilities should be given to her, is this appropriate?
Huang Rong shook her head.
Even the cause of Wang Zonglei's mother's death must be attributed to Huang Rong.
Huang Rong just wants to ask, why?
The mediator spoke at this time.
The mediator looked at both parties and said: "Everyone has something to say. We are mediating and trying to find ways to help everyone solve this matter. If it really can't be solved, go to the court for a lawsuit. After all, it's a lawsuit. The process is very long and quite troublesome, so let’s take it step by step slowly. , and litigation costs money. I hope everyone can communicate calmly and see if we can reach a consensus."
The mediator looked at Wang Zonglei and said, "What are your demands? What? Or, how can you not sue? ”
Wang Zonglei said: "Eight hundred thousand, there is no need to talk about the number below this."
"I am not forcing Huang Rong to go to jail or anything. Huang Rong is in jail or not, and it has nothing to do with me."
"My mother was knocked down, and Huang Rong should bear all the treatment expenses for fifteen days in the hospital."
"The treatment expenses for these fifteen days are sky-high! And my mother died shortly after Huang Rong will also have to bear the funeral expenses. "
"In addition, Huang Rong will also have to pay compensation to my mother. Huang Rong will be responsible for my mother's death. If Huang Rong had paid for the medical expenses earlier, My mother would not have died, and I would not have asked Huang Rong to pay so much money for compensation. Now that Huang Rong caused my mother to die, Huang Rong has to pay a sum of money for compensation.”
Wang Zonglei asked for 800,000 directly.
In other words, Huang Rong gave him 800,000 yuan and he withdrew the lawsuit.
The mediator looked at Huang Rong again.
Huang Rong said: "I think Wang Zonglei himself is at fault in this matter. He clearly knew that his mother was an old man, but he failed to take good care of his mother and walked alone. Don't you No fault? ? And Fan Lijun is an adult herself, even though she is over 60 years old, but she bumps into my suitcase while walking, is it appropriate for me to take all the blame? "
Wang Zonglei said: "Yes, my mother didn't look at the road and accidentally fell down. This was her own fault. I didn't take good care of my mother. I was also at fault. Let's each have 20%. Let's count 40% in total." % of the responsibility, but this matter The cause of the incident still lies with you. You bear 60% of the responsibility and have to pay a total of 480,000 yuan in compensation. I won’t ask you for more. You compensate 480,000 yuan and 15 days of medical expenses. You also paid for it. Just withdraw the lawsuit.”
(End of this chapter)