Chapter 352 Judgment
“Before the promulgation of national standards and the safety of people’s lives, no one is qualified to say, ‘It is reasonable for me to do this.’ Because from the perspective of my client Set out, what the defendant thinks is reasonable is exactly unreasonable! "
" Even well-trained firefighters can't open this door for a while. Since the other party likes to assume, can we also assume that if the person involved in this incident is not Lu? Professor Zhongping was a seriously ill patient. After dialing 120, he died. If the patient loses mobility, even if the ambulance and fire brigade arrive downstairs at the same time, will the patient still have a chance of survival? "
"So we cannot face the unreasonable facts that have already been established. You still have to talk about what is 'reasonable', let alone simply separate doors and locks. Just draw the equal sign.”
“I’ll give you the simplest example—please ask the defendant, from ancient times to the present, have the standards for doors and locks been the same? The safety standards of locks have always been far lower than the safety standards of locks. This is a fact! ”
Depend on! Lawyer Hu suddenly felt sweat on his forehead. The other party was obviously a master and found an angle that could influence the judge's judgment.
“The other side’s lawyer’s statement is suspected of misleading the judge.” Seeing that lawyer Hu was clumsy in his words, Zhou Zhi immediately raised his hand: “Comrade judge, I request to speak.”
“Classmate Zhou Zhi, You can speak, but please note that you can only Answer this question from the prosecution lawyer. "
The judge is actually very interested in this lawsuit, and has seen that both parties seem to be able to accept the outcome of winning or losing. They don't care much about "win or lose". What they care more about is "right or wrong".
"The other party's lawyer pointed out that the safety standards of doors have always been far lower than the safety standards of locks since ancient times. This is true." Zhou Zhi said eloquently: "But he ignored a basic premise, that is, this It is not their subjective will, but the reality that they have to accept due to the restrictions of objective conditions.”
"When objective conditions permit, people's subjective wish is to hope that doors and locks have the same standards and requirements."
"Looking vertically, from ancient times to the present, the design of gates has always been toward We are making unremitting efforts in the direction of becoming more solid.”
“Looking horizontally, the more important places, where conditions permit, The door used is also becoming stronger.”
“So no matter how you look at it, making the door stronger and stronger has always been the goal pursued by the people. I hope that the judges will not be affected by the remarks made by the other party’s lawyer. My statement is over."
No pursuit, no involvement, just discuss the matter and stop abruptly.
Lao Hu secretly praised again in his heart, this man is also a master!
The reaction is very fast and he knows how to play. The judge likes people like this the most.
It seems that this is a very advantageous point designed by Lawyer Huang. It did have the effect of highlighting Qifeng before, but unexpectedly, it was broken by the other party's little boy in an understatement, and the rhythm was suddenly broken. Messy.
Later, Lawyer Huang also questioned the legality of Zhou Zhi’s patent authorization, believing that Zhou Zhi was under the age of 18 last year and did not meet the conditions of an authorizer.
But Lawyer Hu was well prepared. In addition to various reissued authorization agreements, Zhou Zhi even asked his mother to copy and sign, and then used the post office's high-end equipment - a fax machine - to pass the guardian's authorization letter. Be prepared properly.
Under such a complete defense, Lawyer Huang's offense was obviously weak. In the end, the judge pronounced: "The plaintiff Lu Zhongping sued Guanghan Hongqi Security Door Factory for causing safety hazards due to quality problems, and jointly sued Jingyang Jinan Locks Co., Ltd., as well as the security door patent licensor Zhou Zhi, this court It was agreed upon that, based on According to the existing national standards and safety regulations, authorized by the patent inventor Zhou Zhi and sub-authorized by Jingyang Jinan Locks Co., Ltd., the security doors produced by Guanghan Hongqi Security Door Factory fully comply with the highest national C-level standards and are free from defects. …”
< br>
“…To sum up, this incident is consistent with the characteristics of adverse consequences caused by improper use of products by users. The patent inventor Zhou Zhi and Jingyang Jinan Lock Co., Ltd. should not Bear the legal consequences arising from this lawsuit. The costs will be borne by the plaintiff Lu Zhongping. If the plaintiff is dissatisfied with the judgment, he can file a second lawsuit with the higher people's court."
After the verdict was announced, both parties to the case were invited to the studio by Li Xin. Hall, a secondary debate was held.
The two sides were not at war with each other, but rather felt a bit sympathetic to each other. In the end, the focus of the conflict was pointed at the lack of national standards.
In addition, the public utility department did not control new things in a timely manner. My cousin demonstrated on the spot that with the help of professional special tools, it is not that troublesome to dismantle a safety door lock.
But this also involves a safety issue, that is, under what circumstances is it legal to use this professional special tool? Can it be used by maintenance personnel of the manufacturer, or must it be authorized and supervised by relevant personnel in the public utility department? The problem can only be used under certain circumstances.
To expand further, it is about the relevant legal issues involved in opening the door of residents' residences. Here, Lawyer Huang and Lawyer Hu started a heated discussion. In the end, no specific results were discussed, but the two parties reached an agreement. Consistent, that is, the formulation of the entire workflow and related procedures is imminent.
The program ended with a happy ending. Xu Anran, the legal representative and chief engineer of Jinan Locks Co., Ltd., believed that although he was sued by Professor Lu Zhongping, he had no personal feelings for Professor Lu Zhongping. What an opinion, and I admire it very much.
He believes that this case may be of great help to the country in formulating security door level standards as soon as possible; formulating standard procedures for relevant personnel in public utility departments to deal with similar incidents; strengthening professional training; clarifying legal boundaries, etc. Promoting effect.
And such promotion is undoubtedly benign and beneficial to the industry in which we work.
Therefore, in order to repay the lawsuit filed by Professor Lu Zhongping, Xu Anran decided to reinstall a security door for Professor Lu at the company's expense.
The program was broadcast three days after the verdict of the case was announced. On this day, cousin An Ran, cousin An An, and sister Can Can moved a TV to the office of the container house and watched it there. .
As soon as the program showed the supplementary scene of firefighters using an electric grinder to open the lock, the phone on the table began to ring.
Cousin Anxin grabbed the phone: "Hello, Jin'an Locks, who is it...ah, hello...yes, I am Xu Anxin, you are so considerate...ah, yes, yes, we Also at the production gate, the brand has been registered with the Trademark Office The registered one is called Jinou brand... Don't worry, the quality is exactly the same. You can understand that it is Professor Lu's brand that has changed... Hey, wait, let me remember, fifty sets, right? Okay, bye!”
This was just the beginning, and then the calls started to come in succession, and orders came in like a snowflake, one after another.
In addition to orders, there are also merchants with a keen sense of smell who are talking about authorization, consignment, and cooperation...
(End of this chapter)