"However, the facts are disappointing. A power that does not pay attention to the protection of its own cultural relics innocently diverted public attention to my client in order to divert public opinion after the precious cultural heritage that should have been under its protection was stolen. This is absolutely unacceptable.”
“Since my client’s lawsuit, his art gallery business has been in a state of flux. The business that was once busy has turned into a desolate one. Under the deliberate guidance of public opinion, he has faced too many unfounded accusations from people who don’t know the truth. He is under heavy psychological pressure and even affects his personal health. "
"Objection! Your Honor, please state the facts of the case without introducing too much irrelevant emotional incitement." Tony Huang raised his hand.
"The prosecution's request is established." The black aunt nodded: "Defense, please note that this is the closing argument. Please try to provide words that will help determine the value. Continue."
"Yes." At least on the surface, the other party's lawyer still looks good: "Yes. Regarding several so-called evidences presented by the prosecution, we still believe that the court should not accept them. The other party pointed out that the relief statue of a military commander owned by my client is consistent with the style of the remaining Sanle statue and the relief of a group of dwarfs serving women in Wang Chuzhi's tomb. , we think it is completely unacceptable.”
"From the image point of view, the warrior statues are fierce and tough, with angry eyebrows and exaggerated shapes, while the women on the Sanle statues and the reliefs of the servant pictures have gentle and soft looks. The two images are very different and they are by no means the same style. !"
"Furthermore, if both From the same tomb, why are the colors on the reliefs of the servants blurry and blurry, but the warrior figures are clear and unusual? Even if a child were to identify the two photos, it would be impossible to think that the two statues were from the same place. A place."
"So. Please ask the judge and jury to reject the prosecution’s unreasonable demands, protect my client’s legitimate rights and interests, and do not let the justice that my client cannot get in the East also not get in the West.”
Just in Tony Huang. When he was about to protest again, the other party said quickly: "My statement is over, thank you."
Zhou Zhi couldn't help but feel his teeth itch with hatred. These litigators really know how to talk. If he were a jury with no connection, he would not listen to Tony Huang's statement. Before the speech, I felt that what this guy said was pretty much the same.
If you have some prejudice against China, this statement may really have the effect of preconceptions.
Fortunately, Tony Huang had been on guard against this trick for a long time. When selecting the jury, he listed this as the top priority and screened it. This made Zhou Zhi have a high opinion of Tony Huang, who was about to stand up. Take a look.
Damn it, you really have to rely on litigators to deal with them!
“Dear Judge, Dear Jury, this case that originated in China but needs to be pronounced in New York has now attracted a certain amount of attention around the world, and everyone You can make subjective judgments based on your own observations. This is The simplest fact is also the most basic quality of the jury. I think there is no need for the other party to remind you of this. "
Someone in the jury box has begun to smile. It seems that Tony Huang is simple. One word destroyed most of the opponent's attempts to provoke confrontation.
"We have always believed that we need to pursue this case based on the facts of the case, and we have been doing so, working hard to provide the prosecutor with all the evidence and information needed until just now."
"Please allow I will first refute the other party’s two points of view. “First, the other party reported that the styles of the warrior statues and the images of the female servants are inconsistent.” Tony Huang said: “Here, the other party secretly changed the concept. Confusing style and subject matter, trying to deceive our respected judges and juries with distorted reasons."
"The images of warriors, Sanle and servant reliefs are indeed different. , but this is due to the different functions of the two. "
"The warrior is used to suppress evil, exorcise ghosts, and protect the owner, so its shape must be exaggerated, and the expression is frowning. "
"And images such as Sanle reflect secular characters and scenes of singing and dancing life, showing the wealthy life of the tomb owner, and their characters must be amiable, so this difference is reasonable and inevitable;"
"But this is a difference in image selection and shaping methods caused by the subject matter. We are talking about similar styles, not Here."
"We all know that an important part of legal evidence collection is handwriting identification," Tony Huang confidently explained: "A person's writing style and habits will be included. In his handwriting, whether he was reverently copying the Bible or casually signing a check, the two handwritings are just like ours. The statues of warriors and the statues of female attendants are generally different, but their styles are completely different."
"The chisels of the craftsmen are their pens, and the images they create are theirs. If the handwriting is made by the same craftsmen, it will definitely leave the same stylistic characteristics as the calligraphy.”
“Please look at the comparison of these photos.” Tony Huang showed several photos to the jury and the black aunt: “Look at these details. Can you tell me what the difference is in the slope, the expression of the creases at the corners, and the depth of the inward folds? ”
"Let's take a look at these photos again." Tony Huang showed a few more pictures: "What is shown here is the processing of straight lines and curves. Take a look at the depth of the groove, the concave arc, and the edge features. The differences are Where? "
"I can tell you now." Tony Huang walked to the big white board with pictures of the relief statues of military commanders and pictures of the attendants: "Now I can tell you the reliefs you have seen. The edge details, the corners, the folded edges, the odd-numbered ones are from the reliefs of generals, the even-numbered ones are from the attendant group portraits, and they are from here, here, here, and here."
Everyone. I took the picture and searched according to the picture, and sure enough I found the same places as the photo in my hand. Only then did I find that the two statues, which seemed to be expressed in completely different ways, had so many similarities in details.
“We can see from the details of the two statues that skilled craftsmen in ancient China could present different visual effects for different themes, but the craftsmanship standards they used to express different themes were completely different. Unified. This is why we solemnly declare that the styles of the two are completely unified.”
"As for the reason for the huge difference in surface color between the two, according to the archaeological survey report, we can know that the Sanle and Shishi statues are in the back room of the tomb, which was robbed by ancient tombs in the Jin Dynasty, that is, more than a thousand years ago. Thieves penetrated it, and rainwater flowed into the back room of the tomb along the robber hole for thousands of years, eventually causing this result. ”
"It's both lucky and unfortunate because Wang Chuzhi's tomb also has a 'pseudo front room' between the front room and the back room specially designed to prevent theft. This fake room has deceived all tomb robbers for thousands of years. , until a few months ago, it was finally discovered by a group of tomb robbers.”
“This warrior relief statue came from the front room that has never been destroyed, so the coloring can be so well preserved. This is natural. ."(End of this chapter)