Chapter 159: You told me that this was written by an undergraduate? !
As a journal reviewer, when looking at the content of a paper, you often look at the paper team first, whether you are an acquaintance or a big shot in the industry.
It's so real.
Human relationships are everywhere, and reviewers are also human beings, and they also have joy, anger, sorrow, happiness, emotions, and six desires.
Two papers of the same quality, one is an acquaintance and the other is a stranger, and everyone knows how to choose.
The second is title, summary, and conclusion.
See whether the contributions in this article are reliable, whether the existing research mentioned at the beginning and whether it is suitable for the ones mentioned at the end.
Generally at this point, Zeng Yu will make a preliminary judgment that he will directly reject the manuscript or continue to review the manuscript.
His professionalism is enough to support him in making the above judgments. It is not that he has to finish reading to draw a conclusion.
This is an academic paper, not an online novel, and it doesn't matter if there is no such thing as a little poison in the previous chapter. The plot begins to be exciting after ten chapters.
If the title and summary are not up to standard, I will reject it directly.
You can't even handle such a simple part well, and you're embarrassed to say that you are doing academic research?
It would be better to reject the manuscript as soon as possible so that people can submit another person, so that they can avoid waiting for a month or two before waiting for the news of rejecting the manuscript, or they will still be rejected after the overhaul. That would be despair and disgusting.
If all the above parts are fine, he will look at whether the data graph is done well and whether it can match the conclusion of the paper.
After reading all these, and there is no big problem, the value of this paper is at least above the overhaul.
However, the overhaul does not mean that you will definitely be able to pass the draft.
It's just that you have the opportunity, you have to look at the specific content of the article.
Most reviewers will not read your paper word by word. For example, Zeng Yu is very busy and has multiple jobs. He will only have time to read a paper when he comes back at night. , at most 20-30 minutes to see.
Not even 20 minutes!
Then he will simply look at the chapter titles and data charts, and use these to determine whether the paper is valuable.
If you can't figure out your logic, even if this paper is valuable, its value is very limited, and it is understandable to make an instruction to reject the manuscript.
It's really not intentionally to make things difficult.
If the innovative points proposed by the article are attractive enough, then he will definitely be willing to spend more time reading them.
When all the above successfully attracts the reviewer, he will have the patience to read the entire paper.
Maybe he is not qualified enough, but I believe that most reviewers have similar mentality to him.
Yes, he is also a student, and knows that writing a paper is not easy, but this doesn’t mean you can write a few tricks and fool others!
At least, write something valuable, right?
Otherwise, even if he is an acquaintance, he would be embarrassed to give the manuscript.
Because of their "Youth Society Research", the number of drafts that have been reviewed each year is limited, usually twice that of drafts that have been reviewed.
If there are too many drafts in the initial review, which is far lower than the number of drafts in the final review, then you need to think about whether the professional level is enough to support an individual as a reviewer.
...
This paper, which takes the perspective of Marxist political economy, studies the impact of high-priced bride prices on Jiangbei region. After careful reading, there are still some innovations.
And there are quite a few.
The whole article has clear thinking logic and sufficient arguments, and the data graph is beautifully made Zeng Yu really shine.
I can't even find too many points that require overhaul.
Even if there is, it is an insignificant part.
This is very powerful. She is obviously a veteran of thesis, or has guidance from experts behind it.
Even if their "Youth Society Research" is only a C expansion, the review standards for the production of Beijing University will not be much lower than those of other C issues.
What can be seen by Zeng Yu is naturally not the average level.
But at the end, when he saw the author's self-report or self-recommendation letter, his face became a little strange.
"Tell me, is this a paper written by an undergraduate graduate? No team, no tutor?"
Wodefa!
If it is true, it is a bit outrageous.
Even from the perspective of a doctoral supervisor, this article still has certain research value and is very complete. He may not be able to write master's students or even doctoral students under his name.
However, suddenly someone told him that the person who wrote this thesis was actually an undergraduate.
Are you teasing me?
Whose commander is this, so brave?
It's very...I don't know how to describe his current mood. It's shocked and unbelievable, but it's very complicated! "Can it be the result of someone else's plagiarism or robbing directly?" Zeng Yu frowned.
But then I thought about it, there was no team or supervisor for the person who wrote this paper. Where did he plagiarize? Where to grab the results?
Looking at the whole text, it is indeed a conclusion drawn by field visits and investigations. There are hundreds of sample data as references. Even if the analysis results are biased, it is enough to reflect the local reality.
Faced with this situation, Zeng Yu was also a little numb.
Even if they are studying for master's degree, they rarely publish their own works, let alone undergraduates.
If it is true, the author of this paper should have done a lot of preparations in advance and read a lot of references, otherwise it would not be possible to complete it so much.
"Why are such people not my students?"
Zeng Yu sighed in his heart.
This is the student he wants. He is extremely talented and able to do research and write papers down-to-earth. Which tutor is not moved?
Faced with this situation, he really couldn't bear to refuse the manuscript. If you keep such a paper with a quality above the passing line because of the other party’s education and degree, then what is the significance of this journal they run?
The contribution threshold is to filter low-quality manuscripts, rather than filtering them out with high-quality manuscripts.
As we all know, Peking University is a highly academic and school-oriented institution, and the teachers of the school will also be affected by this aspect.
Educational discrimination should not occur here at Beijing University.
However, since he served as a reviewer, this journal has never had a precedent for publishing a single undergraduate degree. I cannot guarantee that after the initial review is passed, the review will be passed at all.
The right to review or even the right to final decision are not with him.
What he can do is to submit the paper to the deputy editor for review, and at the same time attach his own review opinions.
"Give it a headache!"
Enjoy, but he can only do his part.
…
Panshan Haoyuan Villa Area.
Li Beixing went upstairs to take a shower after dinner.
No mistakes, one song, one content, one in 6, one book, one bar, one reading!
Li Qiguang and Jiang Zhiqin were watching TV news in the first floor living room.
But Li Qiguang seemed a little absent-minded today, and his attention was completely out of his TV news. He was distracted and he didn't react immediately when he shouted.
This is not common.
Jiang Zhiqin asked, "Why didn't you say a few words in the night? Are you having any trouble at work?"
Li Qiguang was stunned and didn't know what to say.
"Isn't it easy for me to know?" Jiang Zhiqin felt even more strange when she saw him hesitating.
Li Qiguang quickly shook his head: "I don't know how to speak."
"If you have something to do, just say it. No matter how bad it is, it can be broken." Jiang Zhiqin smiled.
Li Qiguang is afraid that she won't laugh later.
Facing his wife's exploring gaze, he had to sigh and say, "The good girl may have a boy she likes."
Ha?
Jiang Zhiqin was really stunned: "How do you know?"
"When I went to dinner with my friend at noon, I saw her sitting with her for dinner, alone two people. You know the character of a woman. When did this happen? "
Li Qiguang's eyes were full of worries.
He only had one daughter and said he was not worried was fake.
I have been well protected since I was a child. It is a bit too much to say that I am not familiar with the world. At least I have never had much contact with the dark side of society. Even after graduation, I still retain my positive and cheerful side.
Although Jiang Zhiqin was surprised, she didn't whine, but asked curiously: "What kind of person is it?"
Li Qiguang shook his head: "The distance is a bit far, I didn't see it too clearly. But I asked Ah Hui to observe it secretly, and he said he was quite handsome. "
"Then what are you going to do?" Jiang Zhiqin asked with a smile.
Li Qiguang had no choice but to observe first, and find someone to ask about the other party’s situation. What else can you do? It won’t be like breaking up a couple. If the other party’s character is acceptable in all aspects, they are in love with each other, and parents can still be What did you say? There is only support."
Jiang Zhiqin nodded slightly, pondered for two seconds, and said, "Since she doesn't say it, it means it's not time to confess. Pretend to not knowing first. "
Shut down, and smiled and said, "It may not be a good thing. You must believe in the good girl's own vision. She has never made us worry over the years."
Li Qiguang nodded : "Yes!"
He had asked Chen Hui to inquire, and there would probably be news soon.
It is hard to say about private information, and some of the information on the surface should be found.
You will know how to deal with it at that time.
…
The next day, weekend.
Chen Jinghao's holiday ended and he took a bus back to the provincial capital to go to work.
Even for high-speed trains, as well as waiting time and going to the station, it still takes five hours. It can only be said that transportation in small cities is indeed far less convenient than that in large cities.
Chen Qiyun was very happy. No one was competing for food with her now. She was hoping to finish her homework quickly so that she could find Chen Jingle to play games on her mobile phone.
Today, we strive to upgrade the king to level 6 and then start playing rankings.
Chen Jingle's point of view is that as long as the learning task is completed, it will not affect learning. Appropriate entertainment is OK, combining work and rest.
Learning focuses on efficiency, not about who spends more time studying.
I just finished tutoring Chen Qiyun's homework and was about to go to cook.
Suddenly, Liang Cheng slapped on WX and threw a promotional poster for Jiangbei local real estate projects.
What's the thing?
(This chapter ends)