Chapter 402 How could Gu Chen lose the lawsuit?
Gu Chen continued: "This is a conditioned reflex, a subconscious conditioned reflex when encountering this situation."
"The old man thought it was a grenade, but in fact it was just a piece of potato. But the old man always dreamed about the nightmare he had when he was young. He always dreamed about being able to block the grenade with his body. He would rather die than his brother. ”
"The old man has lived for so many years, how can he not know where there are grenades in modern society?"
"It can't be his first time on a bus. How could there be a grenade on the bus?"
"Besides, this old man has been a soldier. Although he is old now, he is not confused."
"But when he saw the potatoes falling, he still jumped on them regardless of his own safety."
"This is an instinctive reaction, an instinct engraved in the bones!"
"Does the old man need to react? Does the old man need to think about what to do?"
"Just like my client Li Long, Li Long and this old man suffered the same result, both of their closest relatives died."
"But the process is different."
"The old man is a soldier and can take revenge with his own hands!"
"But it was his mother who died when Li Long died, and he watched all this!"
"This has become a lifelong shadow for him!"
"You said that Li Long had a clear motive for committing the crime, cruel means of committing the crime, and a clear plan for committing the crime?"
"And what I want to say is that Li Long doesn't need any crime plan or means at all!"
"He is a mental patient. When he does these things, it is enough to follow his instincts."
Gu Chen finished speaking.
The audience burst into applause.
The audience in the auditorium burst into applause.
Everyone understood what Gu Chen said
Because Li Long encountered the death of his mother when he was a child, the shadow of his childhood has been with him to this day, and has seriously affected Li Long's mental state.
Li Long is a mental patient.
How meticulous a crime plan is needed to avenge your mother?
Li Long just kills people with a knife at night
He just wanted to take revenge and help his mother get revenge.
Li Long is a mental patient, but Li Long is not a real thug!
The three people he killed, Lu Jun, Lu Wang, and Lu Daniu, were all the murderers of his mother.
There were other passers-by passing by at that time, but Li Long didn't even look at these passers-by.
Moreover, these three people were not the only ones in Lu Hai's family at that time.
It happened to be the National Day, and the whole family was there.
Li Long let irrelevant people go.
Every wrongdoer has his own debtor, and he just wants to kill the murderer!
He could clearly identify these three murderers.
Gu Chen said: "To put it bluntly, my client Li Long has a mental illness, and he did not harm innocent people. These three people were all murderers who killed his mother. I don't think Li Long has any social danger, nor I also feel that the nature of Li Long’s crime is not that serious. Li Long did not intentionally kill anyone, he is just a mental patient who cannot tell what he is doing.”
"Such a mentally ill person does no harm if he does not kill innocent people indiscriminately. Moreover, Li Long has been mentally ill for so many years, and he has not harmed anyone."
"Li Long only did something to punish the murderer of his mother. I don't think what Li Long did was that bad. To avenge his mother, isn't it bad? Setting fire to the car, what does it prove? The car that was burned was also The Army vehicle did not damage public property.”
Everyone around was silent.
No one can refute Gu Chen.
It's really not illegal to kill someone with a mental illness.
Public prosecutor Wang Qing coughed.
Wang Qing finally said: "I still believe that Li Long had a clear motive for killing three people. He was self-aware at the time of the crime, and it was not an unconscious killing. Otherwise, how could he only kill Lu Lu, Lu Wang, and Lu Daniu? No matter how the defense lawyer explains it, I still stand by my opinion.”
No matter what happens, Wang Qing can't stand on Gu Chen's side.
She must find a way to convict Li Long.
Li Long killed three people. If Li Long is not convicted, then where is the majesty of the law?
Gu Chen directly wanted to defend Li Long and get him acquitted. Who can accept this?
No matter what the court decides, or how Gu Chen explains in court, she must hold Li Long accountable.
Wang Qing said: "Even if this incident has cast a shadow on Li Long, Li Long still has self-awareness and is not completely devoid of self-awareness."
After Gu Chen heard this, he said: "The old man who took the initiative to put the potatoes under his body on the bus, doesn't he have self-awareness? We are China, not a certain country. How could there be grenades on the bus? How could the old man not know this after being in our country for so many years? This is just instinctive and unconscious.”
Wang Qing said: "You are right, but the old man only reacted instinctively for a moment, which is human nature and understandable. But Li Long was killing people, killing people continuously. After the army escaped, Li Long chased him and killed him. Killing, do you think this is a momentary instinct?"
Gu Chen smiled and said: "The old man is a normal person, and he is also a soldier."
"But Li Long is just a mental patient."
"Mental patients have no self-awareness when they commit crimes."
"It's just that these three people happened to be the enemies in Li Long's memory, so Li Long chased these three people desperately and did not harm other people."
Wang Qing shook her head, "I don't think the defendant's lawyer's point of view is correct. Li Long only pursued these three people. Doesn't this prove that it was a vendetta? Doesn't this prove that Li Long has self-awareness? If he does not have self-awareness, Should Li Long go after others? ”
Gu Chen said: "Then I will talk about another case here."
"First of all, we must make a clear point. When a mentally ill patient becomes ill, he has no self-awareness and does not know what he is doing. It is purely an instinctive reaction."
"There is a kind of bull called Spanish bullfighting. He will attack the red cloth waved by the bullfighter."
"Do you think this cow can have self-awareness like humans?"
"This cow has no self-awareness, but it will keep attacking the person holding the red cloth."
"This kind of cow will attack indiscriminately only under rare circumstances. In most cases, it will always attack the person holding the red cloth."
"Li Long also had no self-awareness at the time. He attacked people just because these three people were like the red cloth held by the matador to him."
"It is precisely because Li Long does not have self-awareness that he pursues these three people crazily, regardless of others."
Gu Chen continued: "If Li Long was not mentally ill at the time and had self-awareness, then it would be impossible for Li Long to kill only Lu Jun, King Lu, and Lu Daniu."
"For Li Long, if he has self-awareness, he will know that after killing someone, he will definitely be sentenced to death, especially if he kills three people in a row, Li Long will definitely be sentenced to death in the end."
"For Li Long, there is no difference between killing three people and killing Lu Jun's family. It happened to be night, and there were at least a dozen people in the Lu family, but Li Long only killed these three people."
"If Li Long had self-awareness at the time, he would not have killed these three people. You have to know that it is entirely possible for a person who has really planned for a long time and has a will to die to kill everyone."
"If Li Long is really rational, he may do even more unimaginable things, and the consequences will be more serious."
"On the contrary, the fact that Li Long's goal has always been these three people shows that he does not have any self-awareness. All he has in his mind is the nightmare he had when he was a child."
"My statement is complete."
Gu Chen finished speaking.
This time, even the prosecutor didn’t know how to refute.
The prosecutor felt something was wrong. But he couldn't refute Gu Chen.
She always felt that Li Long's murder targets were these three people, which showed that Li Long was self-aware.
As a result, Gu Chen's explanation made the prosecutor a little confused.
How to defend this?
Because what Gu Chen said was completely correct.
Li Long went to take revenge, not to visit everyone.
What's the difference between killing three people and killing a bunch of people?
Aren't they all punishable by death?
In this case, why not let the murderer bear more pain?
Li Long might kill the whole family, but he could do it.
Because for a murderer, there is no difference between killing three people and killing five people.
Netizens in the live broadcast room also liked it.
[Damn it, Lawyer Gu’s defense angle. 】
[Awesome. There is hope for this case. 】
[I don’t know how the verdict will be, but I really know how good Attorney Gu is in litigating this case. 】
[This lawsuit is really perverted. The prosecutor doesn’t even know what to say. 】
[This case really has a chance. The key lies in how the court decides in the end. 】
Netizens all spoke one after another.
Prosecutor Wang Qing has fallen silent.
She has said everything she can say, and now it depends on how the court decides.
The presiding judge Xu Yang looked at Li Long and said, "Does the defendant have anything to say?"
At this time, Li Long spoke.
Li Long said: "Gu Chen is just farting! I am not a psychopath, I am also conscious! Who said I am unconscious? Who said I am a psychopath? I want to avenge my mother, and I just want to kill these three people. What's wrong with me? I just want to kill them! I still feel that I'm not wrong!"
"Now I finally say it, I am so awake! I saw these three people are still alive, but my mother has left, I am very unhappy, I just want to find them!! They must die!!!"
“My lawyer is telling you nonsense!”
"I just want to kill them!! No one can do it!!"
"I don't think I did anything wrong. What's wrong with killing them? Huh?"
"That's all I have to say. Anyway, I plead guilty. The worst you can do is sentence me to death. I don't care. I can see my mother!"
After Li Long finished speaking, he laughed.
This joy of revenge.
He finally has his revenge!
He also left money for his father.
He has no regrets anymore.
death penalty?
Li Long is not afraid of the death penalty at all.
After his execution, he might be able to see his mother again.
As for fear? What's there to fear about the death penalty?
He just said this openly in court, and there was nothing anyone could do.
Public prosecutor Wang Qing seized the opportunity and said: "President, the defendant has admitted all his crimes and also stated that he wanted revenge. This shows that he had a clear motive for committing the crime, a clear plan to commit the crime, and he was not sick when he committed the crime. , he admitted everything. He just wanted to avenge his mother. This was intentional homicide, and the unintentional crime claimed by the defendant's defense lawyer was all false! Even the client admitted it, and the defendant's defense lawyer's defense was just that. Ridiculous.”
Li Long nodded, "Yes, I just admitted it, and I just want revenge. Hahaha, what's wrong? You give me the death penalty! It doesn't matter!"
After Li Long finished speaking, the entire audience fell into complete silence.
Li Long admitted everything.
He confessed directly to the crime himself.
No matter how good the preparation Gu Chen made, it had no effect.
Gu Chen said that Li Long was mentally ill and that Li Long committed the crime unconsciously.
As long as Li Long doesn't say anything, there is a high probability that this case will be acquitted in the end.
But these last few words Li Long said were going to turn him from innocent to death!
Finished
All is lost.
Xia Ranran shook her head and sighed, "It's over. Li Long insists on admitting it. It's hard even if he doesn't want the death penalty. Gu Chen's lawsuit is already about to win, but Li Long himself comes out and insists on pleading guilty. What else can he do? ?”
Gao Yong also hated the fact that iron cannot be made into steel. "Gu Chen has already agreed on everything and will win this lawsuit immediately. Does Li Long have to seek death? After he said this, the prosecutor seized the opportunity, so how could he be acquitted?" Huh? You will still be sentenced to death in the end.”
After all, this case has already happened.
It is impossible for anyone to go back to the beginning and see whether Li Long was conscious at that time and whether he had a mental illness.
These can only be analyzed based on post hoc guesses and reasoning.
Gu Chen's analysis and reasoning just now was so beautiful that it left the prosecutor speechless.
The lawsuit that was already about to be won was shattered because of what Li Long said.
The most critical thing about this case is whether Li Long was self-aware and had a psychotic episode when he committed the crime.
Once a psychotic episode occurs, it is normal to lose consciousness.
Therefore, the law stipulates that once a mentally ill person becomes ill, he is not guilty of murder.
Because mentally ill people don't know what they are doing.
But Li Long kept admitting it.
Directly face to face and use the big move.
Who can do what?
No matter how good Gu Chen's defense was, it was all in vain.
The presiding judge Xu Yang also made up his mind.
This case will be pronounced soon!
Now that the parties involved have said so, the case is almost over.
The netizens in the live broadcast room all hate that iron cannot become steel.
What is Li Long doing?
Such a pure side effect! !
And this time.
Gu Chen glanced at Li Long, not panicking at all.
Can he really lose the lawsuit?
Gu Chen stood up directly and said: "Presiding judge, I have one last sentence to say."
(End of chapter)