Chapter 151 Xie Siyu is not guilty!
After Gu Chen finished speaking of his four demands.
Both Zhang Zhiqiang and Zhu Guizhen at the plaintiff's seat had angry faces.
They are the plaintiffs!
Gu Chen wants to send them in?
Why?
Zhang Zhiqiang raised his hand and spoke: "President, we are the victims! My father is gone! It is because Xie Siyu hit my father with his car, I am the victim, why should she want to victimize us? Why?"
Zhu Guizhen also said: "I am also a victim! It's all her fault! Why do you want to send us in?" >
Xie Siyu raised her hand and spoke, "Because I didn't hit the person, it was not me who hit the person."
After hearing this, Zhang Zhiqiang sneered: "Then let me ask you, you didn't hit the person, so why did you Want to go up and help someone?”
Presiding judge Rong Liwei banged the gavel.
“Silence!”
“Defendant’s lawyer, please speak.”
Everyone looked at Gu Chen.
Gu Chen spoke at this time.
Gu Chen: "This question asked by the plaintiff Zhang Zhiqiang is very interesting. This question is also a question asked by the presiding judge of the first instance to our client, [People are not bumping into each other, why did you go up to help them?]"
"When someone can ask this, I feel chilled."
"Helping others and selfless dedication have been the traditional virtues of the Chinese nation since ancient times. When you see an old man falling on the ground, go and help him. Isn’t it right? When you see an old man lying on the ground with no clue about his life or death, what’s the problem? It’s ridiculous that some people can ask such questions!”
"Is it possible that you have to bump into someone to help you? If you don't bump into someone, you can't help, right? What if one day your father or your mother falls down while walking on the road and can't get up? Her life is in danger. , shouldn’t anyone else help you? Are you willing to let your parents fend for themselves?”
Everyone at the scene fell silent.
The same goes for netizens in the live broadcast room.
【Lawyer Gu said it well! 】
[Indeed, if my parents fell on the road, I would also like to be helped by others. Anyway, our family will not blackmail people. 】
【This kind of old man who blackmails people should bear legal responsibility. It's so disgusting. No one in the whole society dares to help the old man. 】
【It has become a mistake to help the elderly, and good people can be sentenced to ten years in prison. Do you think it is ridiculous? 】
[If Xie Siyu is really sentenced to ten years and ordered to pay a dime, I will no longer help the elderly. 】
【Who dares to help the old man, who has a mine at home? Hahaha, even those who have mines at home don’t dare to help them anymore. If they help an old man and then backhand him, they will be sentenced to ten years in prison. Can you withstand it? 】
Zhang Zhiqiang said: "But you were the one who hit me. The evidence is conclusive. The witnesses and physical evidence are all there. My father was hit by you and his leg was broken! Are you still here to shirk responsibility? And Zhu Guizhen is also here." I saw it, you were the one who hit me!" After hearing this, Zhu Guizhen nodded quickly, "Yes, yes, I am the first person involved! I saw Xie Siyu hit someone with her Mercedes-Benz C! She also hit the old man! I, both of us were knocked out! Xie Siyu still refused to admit it! My eyes are the best evidence! Zhu Guizhen also thought about it herself.
It's impossible for Xie Siyu to hit the old man first and then her, right?
After all, if Xie Siyu really hit the old man, he would have stopped the car, so Zhu Guizhen said that Xie Siyu drove and hit her and the old man together, and she also acted as a witness.
It is precisely because of Zhu Guizhen’s witness in the first trial, and the old man also said that it was Xie Siyu who hit him. There is no evidence of surveillance video at the place where the incident occurred. Moreover, Xie Siyu’s car was an accident car and the driving recorder was also broken. As a result, Xie Siyu was finally found fully responsible, ordered to pay 1.4 million yuan, and be imprisoned for ten years.
The plaintiff's lawyer said: "The chain of evidence is sufficient and complete, and both the witnesses and physical evidence are there. Only Xie Siyu was driving on Changfeng Street where the incident occurred. Both people were hit. It is only possible that Xie Siyu hit him with his car. Yes, so Xie Siyu must bear the responsibility.”
Both the plaintiff’s lawyer and the plaintiff had a tough attitude. Anyway, they insisted that Xie Siyu was responsible for the collision and let Xie Siyu bear the responsibility.
Gu Chen raised his hand.
Presiding judge Rong Liwei looked at Gu Chen and said: "What is the defense of the defendant's lawyer?"
Gu Chen said: "Presiding judge, the plaintiff's lawyer and the plaintiff have been saying It was our client Xie Siyu who hit him, and the first-instance judgment was based on this."
Everyone nodded.
Gu Chen continued: "The plaintiff has been emphasizing that it was Xie Siyu who hit the person. Please provide evidence of the hit. If there is no evidence that Xie Siyu hit the person, then our client is not guilty."
"Is there any surveillance video of the incident site? Is there any evidence that our client, Xie Siyu, hit someone with his car? Is there any evidence?"
The plaintiff Zhang Zhiqiang said: "You are a murderer, even my father was hit. He’s dead! How can you say something like this when he’s dead in the hospital? ? Then why did my father die?”
: "The hospital reported that your father died of a heart attack. Did your father die on the spot after being hit?"
Zhang Zhiqiang chuckled, "My father said it was Xie Siyu who hit him, so it was Xie Siyu who hit him. It can't be Was my father a liar? If it wasn't Xie Siyu who hit her, how could my dad have suffered multiple injuries? And Yan Guizhen also saw it with her own eyes. Wasn't the witness evidence that it was? Why should we deny the person who hit Xie Siyu? "
Zhu Guizhen said from the side: "It was Xie Siyu who hit me. I saw the person who hit Xie Siyu with my own eyes! And why do we need to provide evidence? Didn't we provide evidence? ? Then you ask Xie Siyu to prove that she did not hit anyone, and the front of the car Xie Siyu drove was deformed! How did you do it! ”
Gu Chen said: "Legally, whoever claims the evidence has to give evidence. Just relying on the testimony of the two of you cannot be used as evidence. In other words, you two have no evidence that Xie Siyu hit someone, which means that Xie Siyu is not guilty. "
The plaintiff's lawyer said: "Lawyer Gu, this is a fallacy. If a car runs over a person to death on a road without surveillance video, the person who was run over cannot produce evidence. Then is the owner of this car not guilty? "
"Both parties said that it was Xie Siyu who hit the person, that is, unless Xie Siyu can produce evidence that she did not hit the person, such as Dashcam video, otherwise she should bear full responsibility for this case. Since she hit someone, why not take responsibility? "
"The person who bullied us did not understand the law and evidence, so Xie Siyu hit someone? You don’t have to take any responsibility?”
(End of this chapter)