Chapter 152 The Killing
Gu Chen said: “There were no surveillance cameras on the road where the incident occurred, and Xie Siyu’s Mercedes-Benz C happened to be involved in an accident on the day of the incident. The vehicle was damaged and the driving recorder was damaged. It was damaged, so there is no surveillance video.”
“And I have two photos in my hand. The photo of the vehicle after Xie Siyu’s car was involved in the accident is as follows.”
“The other photo is of the old man. Zhu Guizhen said that the photo taken after Xie Siyu hit them was also a Mercedes-Benz C. The Mercedes-Benz C was still exactly the same as the previous photo, with no change in appearance. "
"And this was the photo taken by Xie Siyu that afternoon. From the speed of driving on Changfeng Street, it can be seen that Xie Siyu’s driving speed has been maintained at about 20-30km/h, at a constant speed throughout the journey, and he stopped slowly at the end, without any sudden braking.”
"There happens to be no traffic lights or zebra crossings on this section of Changfeng Street. The probability that Xie Siyu will hit Zhang Guobin and Zhu Guizhen at the same time while driving is very low. Unless Zhang Guobin and Zhu Guizhen know each other and are walking together, there will be no chance. They may have been hit at the same time."
Gu Chen continued: "As for Zhang Guobin's physical condition, he has a broken leg and multiple wounds on his body, but Zhu Guizhen did not see any wounds on his body. The car hit Zhang Guobin and Zhu Guizhen at the same time. It is impossible that Zhang Guobin suffered a fracture and Zhu Guizhen had no injuries at all. "
"Of course, some people may say that the old man's body is more fragile."
"Zhu Guizhen, let me ask you, since you are the person involved, where did Xie Siyu hit you when he hit someone with his car? From where in the vehicle did he hit you?"
Zhu Guizhen said with dodge in her eyes. : "How come I still remember it so clearly? If you hit someone, you have to take responsibility! I only remember that Xie Siyu drove very fast and knocked both of us away! It's just that I was thick-skinned and not injured!"
Gu Chen said: "Judging from the speed at which Xie Siyu was driving, there was no sudden braking at that speed, so it was impossible for Xie Siyu's car to knock Zhang Guobin and Zhu Guizhen out. If the two people were hit, because there was no sudden braking, the vehicle It was parking slowly, so Zhang Guobin and Zhu Guizhen would be rolled under the car at the same time."
"First, it is impossible for Xie Siyu to slow down even if he sees the person on his face. The deceleration must be a sudden braking, according to the vehicle's speed. Looking at the driving trajectory, Xie Siyu did not brake suddenly, so there is no situation where Xie Siyu hit anyone. "
"Secondly, even if he hit someone, because he did not brake suddenly, 20- At a speed of 30km/h, it is impossible for the vehicle to knock Zhang Guobin and Zhu Guizhen out. If they were hit, Zhu Guizhen would not be completely injured. Moreover, the moment Zhang Guobin and Zhu Guizhen were hit by the car, the parts of their bodies that were hit would also be injured. , so it can be inferred that Xie Siyu did not hit anyone with his car. "
"Third, if two people were rolled under the car and Zhang Guobin suffered a fracture, then Xie Siyu would immediately call 120, 110, and Zhang Guobin. It must still be under the car, and Zhang Guobin was far away from the vehicle at the time of the incident. He had multiple wounds on his body. The wounds were not caused by the impact of the vehicle, let alone the crushing of the vehicle. With Xie Siyu alone, he could not Maybe he held Zhang Guobin far away from the vehicle. "
"Fourth, if Xie Siyu really hit someone with his car, it would be impossible for one person to be injured and the other person to be fine. "
"Fifth, Zhang Guobin and Zhu Guizhen could not produce any evidence that Xie Siyu hit someone. They would only keep repeating verbally that it was Xie Siyu who hit someone."
"To sum up, our client Xie Siyu He didn’t hit anyone.”
Gu Chen’s words were logical and the process was very reasonable.
Because there is no video evidence in this case, the conclusion at the time can only be reached through various analyses.
A normal driver will inevitably brake suddenly when he is about to hit someone.
But Xie Siyu didn't make any sudden braking movements from beginning to end, which means she didn't hit anyone at all!
Furthermore, Xie Siyu’s driving skills are not bad, and there is no such thing as using the accelerator as the brake.
At this time, the evidence is obvious!
Gu Chen said: "Moreover, Zhu Guizhen kept saying that she was knocked away. This is completely slander. The vehicle did not brake suddenly. How could it be possible that the speed of 20-30km/h would knock you away? Even if it was hit, you would be knocked away. "No, you don't have any wounds on your body, that's even more nonsense." Gu Chen analyzed as he spoke.
Netizens in the live broadcast room have already exploded.
【Holy shit, is Lawyer Gu so awesome? 】
【Is this Lawyer Gu’s ability to analyze cases? Xie Siyu really didn't hit anyone. 】
【Although there is no driving recorder, there are specific driving conditions and driving records of the vehicle at that time. I looked at it and found that the car was really slowing down. 】
[Xie Siyu must have not hit anyone, otherwise she would have just taken the insurance. Anyway, the insurance paid for it, but she didn't hit anyone. She went to help someone out of kindness, but she was blackmailed out of her money. It's disgusting. 】
[Lawyer Gu is awesome! ! ! 】
【I understand! ! 】
【Damn, those two people are blackmail! Blackmail requires responsibility! ! 】
[Indeed, isn’t blackmail blackmail? You must be held responsible for extortion! 】
【You can’t just let people blackmail you casually, right? 】
Zhang Zhiqiang said dissatisfied: "Who knows all the nonsense you are talking about? Anyway, the situation is very simple. It was your car at the time of the incident, and you were the one who hit it!! You also caused the fractures!! You must take responsibility!!! "
Zhu Guizhen also yelled: "I saw it with my own eyes! It was you who hit me! What are you talking about? You hit someone and you don't admit it? What are you analyzing? "
Presiding judge Rong Liwei banged his gavel, "Quiet!"
Gu Chen said at this time, "You must be careful in court. According to the evidence, the first instance sentenced our client to ten years in prison and paid compensation of 1.4 million. I cannot accept it at all. There is no evidence that Xie Siyu hit someone. According to the logical analysis of what happened, it can be concluded that Xie Siyu did not hit someone. People."
"Is it possible that our client will have to pay money because of someone else's blackmail? "
"Trouble is common nowadays. When did it become a fault for a well-intentioned person to help an old man? When did a well-intentioned person need to prove his innocence when he helped an old man? Why should a good person prove his innocence? Shouldn't bad people bring out video evidence of being hit? What? Can oral evidence also be used as evidence? "
Gu Chen said: "According to speculation, the result can only be this. At the time of the incident, the ground was uneven. Zhang Guobin accidentally fell to the ground while walking, and then Xie Siyu found Zhang Guobin fell to the ground and went to help the old man, but he was extorted money from his backhand. "As for Judge Zhu Guizhen, Zhu Guizhen is a habitual extortionist! According to the evidence in my hand, Zhu Guizhen extorted a total of 100,000 yuan. It has exceeded 200,000 yuan, and the number of blackmails has exceeded 20 times!”
(End of this chapter)